against the need of citizens to know whether their leaders are living
lives of suspicious luxury on meager public-sector salaries.
And because information is related to power, reason is only part
of the debate over how far disclosure should go and when secrecy
should reign. The battles over the right to know versus the right to
withhold also reflect bitter struggles over existing patterns of politi-
cal and economic privilege.
This book contains numerous, wide-ranging stories from the
battlefront: the grassroots campaigns waged in India under the slo-
gan “The right to know is the right to live”; China’s top-down effort
to “informationize” its economy; the ongoing international NGO
campaign to improve the disclosure policies of intergovernmental
organizations such as the World Bank and the International Mon-
etary Fund (IMF); the continuing tensions over whether security
is best promoted by secrecy or by greater openness. These stories
epitomize the enormous range of policy choices now facing national
governments, international organizations, corporations, and citi-
zens’ groups. What laws should govern the rights of citizens to have
access to government-held information, and how can those laws be
meaningfully implemented? To what extent do international orga-
nizations, corporations, and citizens’ groups have an obligation to
reveal information, and to whom? Who is entitled to know what?
And what good does disclosure do?
To start the book off, this introduction defines “transparency”
and lays out the theoretical reasoning behind the claim that publicly
useful information is generally underprovided. Then it provides the
historical context, for the fight to know has a long and significant
past. Finally, it lays out the plan of the rest of the book.
The Meaning and Purposes of Transparency
Although the word “transparency” is widely used, it is rarely well
defined. There is no consensus on what the definition should be
or how transparency should be measured. Such problems are not
unique to the transparency phenomenon. For example, many politi-
cal scientists have made valuable contributions to our understanding
of domestic and international politics without being able to pinpoint
precisely the meaning of so fundamental a concept as “power.” But
introduction: the battle over transparency